Beginner’s Luck is B.S.
I went fishing a few days ago. I was lucky enough to head home for a quick break and headed out on the boat with my parents and brothers to catch some fluke off of Long Island, which I haven’t done in years. In case you don’t know, I’m an expert fisherman. So is my dad. So is my uncle, my neighbor, and the two guys that were on a boat near ours.
We’ve got the shiny multi-colored lures, the right kind of bait for that season and time of the day, and timing perfectly synchronized with the tides. We have the nifty reels and the big tackle box and perhaps most importantly, the best techniques for fluke fishing.
We caught nothing.

My 9-year-old brother, with his hand-me-down fishing rod, hook, and little piece of squid, brought it two nice ones.
But it’s so easy, almost natural, to discount the accomplishment of someone younger/less experienced by chalking it up to ‘luck’. The old guys used to treat my big catches like a miracle of pity from the universe when I was a little kid. And even though I know how much I resented it then, I found myself so quickly chanting “beginner’s luck” at my own brother’s achievement.
Oh, how easy it is.
It’s not luck. And you see 20-year-old kids starting booming businesses? You see the singer with a mediocre voice and decent-but-not-Beetles songwriting skills that is conquering the industry? How about the scrappy people that are building influential, world-changing things on the fly while other better-educated, more experienced peers in their field are stuck in a mediocre dead-end job?
It’s definitely not luck. But it’s also not skill (mostly). Otherwise, the most skilled people would always win, and we all know that’s not the case.
Shouldn’t the more experienced individual who’s more well-versed in their field create the more successful product? Don’t they know what works and what doesn’t work already?
Maybe the beginner’s advantage is just that - they don’t know any better.
A beginner has a short window of opportunity when they have no other choice but to create something relentlessly simple that solves a real problem. Is there a better definition of a successful product?
A beginner can’t get caught up in the cutting edge because they don’t know the cutting edge, nor do they care. They can’t get bogged down by the bells and whistles because they’re committing all their time to the basics. They don’t spend time and energy worrying about what will happen to their reputation because they have none.
So beginners, cherish this precious moment of your life. You’ll never be this way again. Don’t worry about what more experienced people in your field think. Take their advice and listen closely to their criticism, but don’t try and measure up to them. Worry about what your audience, or your customers think.
You can dive in, make (awful) mistakes, learn, repeat, and eventually win. The world may see the magazine cover and call it ‘luck’, but you’ll know what’s really going on.





